| 1795 | Johann Bertram Richarz |
| 1796 | Christian Gottschalk |
| 1797 | Nikolaus Dietz |
| 1798 | Adolph Rhein |
| 1799 | Wilhelm Röttgen |
| 1800 | Michael Richarz |
| 1801 | Johann Nicolaus Hermes |
| 1802 | Ferdinand Nolden |
| 1803 | Michael Dietz |
| 1804 | Heinrich Dahmen |
| 1805 | Heinrich Werner |
| 1806 | Joseph Richarz |
| 1807 | Peter Joseph Hombitzer |
| 1808 | Carl Peter Bauer |
| 1809 | Christian Hombitzer |
| 1811 | Engelbert Rhein |
| 1812 | Peter Effertz |
| 1815 | Mathias Rhein |
| 1816 | Johann Koch |
| 1817 | Paulus Richarz |
| 1818 | Clemens Müllens |
| 1819 | Joseph Dietz |
| 1820 | Wilhelm Joseph Rhein |
| 1821 | Wilhelm Joseph Koch |
| 1822 | Mathias Koch |
| 1823 | Ferdinand Rhein |
| 1824 | Michael Richarz |
| 1825 | Wilhelm Rhein |
| 1827 | Wilhelm Uhrmacher |
| 1828 | Adam Effertz |
| 1829 | Adolph Rhein |
| 1832 | Joseph Betz |
| 1833 | Peter Dahm |
| 1834 | Peter Gödderz |
| 1835 | Heinrich Betz |
| 1836 | Wilhelm Rhein |
| 1837 | Heinrich Uhrmacher |
| 1838 | Jacob Becker |
| 1839 | Engelbert Müllens |
| 1839 | Bartel Dollendorf |
| 1840 | Rudolph Weinstock |
| 1841 | Peter Aloysius Strack |
| 1842 | Johann Heinrich Richarz |
| 1843 | Johann Harf |
| 1844 | Joseph Thomas |
| 1845 | Johann Dohmen |
| 1846 | Lorenz Bergmann |
| 1847 | Christian Weinstock |
| 1848 | Joseph Dietz |
| 1849 | Johann Richarz |
| 1850 | Georg Falkenstein |
| 1851 | Christian Borsig |
| 1852 | Clemens Elles |
| 1853 | Joseph Heinen |
| 1854 | Roland Dietz |
| 1855 | Adolph Harffen |
| 1855 | Jacob Bauer |
| 1856 | Wilhelm Honscheid |
| 1858 | Joseph Bonn |
| 1858 | Heinrich Rönz |
| 1859 | Adolph Thomas |
| 1860 | Wilhelm Braschoss |
| 1861 | Heinrich Bonn |
| 1862 | Jacob Röttgen |
| 1863 | Wilheln Neusser |
| 1864 | Christian Mühlens |
| 1865 | Johann Müller |
| 1866 | Theodor Braschoß |
| 1867 | Hermann Joseph Roenz |
| 1870 | Jakob Dietz |
| 1871 | Wilhelm Dietz |
| 1872 | Bartel Künzler |
| 1873 | Sebastian Müller |
| 1874 | Engelbert Müllens |
| 1875 | Jacob Arenz |
| 1876 | Peter Uhrmacher |
| 1877 | Reiner Retz |
| 1878 | Mathias Horbach |
| 1879 | Barthel Dollendorf |
| 1880 | Ferdinand Richarz |
| 1881 | Jacob Bois |
| 1882 | Adam Schroeder |
| 1883 | Johann Röttgen |
| 1884 | Maximilian Müller |
| 1885 | Johann Falkenstein |
| 1886 | Anton Mittler |
| 1887 | Anton Mittler |
| 1888 | Wilhelm Henscheid |
| 1889 | Peter Müller |
| 1890 | Witmar Bertram |
| 1891 | Jakob Küster |
| 1892 | Theodor Ronig |
| 1893 | Fritz Braschoß |
| 1894 | Karl Thomas |
| 1895 | Ludwig Ronig |
| 1896 | Ludwig Ronig |
| 1897 | Jakob Schmitz |
| 1898 | Wilhelm Lohmar |
| 1899 | Peter Lenz |
| 1900 | Peter Lenz |
| 1901 | Hermann Welter |
| 1902 | Adolph Werner II |
| 1903 | Adolph Werner I |
| 1904 | Adolph Werner I |
| 1905 | Johann Droisdorf |
| 1906 | Johann Droisdorf |
| 1907 | Johann Droisdorf |
| 1908 | Christian Weinstock |
| 1909 | Christian Groll |
| 1910 | Christian Groll |
| 1911 | Johann Künzler |
| 1912 | Johann Künzler |
| 1913 | Johann Gemein |
| 1919 | Nikolaus Werner |
| 1920 | Peter Betz |
| 1920 | Nikolaus Werner |
| 1921 | Stefan Holtorf |
| 1922 | Nikolaus Werner |
| 1923 | Nikolaus Werner |
| 1924 | Nikolaus Werner |
| 1925 | Bernhard Alfter |
| 1926 | Bernhard Alfter |
| 1927 | Bernhard Alfter |
| 1928 | Theo Trommeschläger |
| 1929 | Mathias Krahe |
| 1930 | Mathias Krahe |
| 1931 | Hans Hübel |
| 1932 | Hans Hübel |
| 1933 | Hans Hübel |
| 1934 | Willi Düppen |
| 1935 | Andreas Gemein |
| 1936 | Christian Weinstock |
| 1937 | Wilhelm Peters |
| 1938 | Andreas Gemein |
| 1939 | Andreas Gemein |
| 1946-1950 | Willi Marner |
| 1950-1952 | Karl Theil |
| 1952-1959 | Heinz Willmeroth |
| 1959-1964 | Hans-Theo Alfter |
| 1964-1967 | Hans-Peter Ehl |
| 1967-1972 | Dieter Wittmann |
| 1972-1976 | Ulrich Köhr |
| 1976-1979 | Peter Gassen |
| 1979-1984 | Eugen Rosbach |
| 1984-1991 | Manfred Krahe |
| 1991-1995 | Ulrich Volkmer |
| 1995-1998 | Stefan Groll |
| 1998-2001 | Guido Stelter |
| 2001-2002 | Thomas Keppelstraß |
| 2002-2009 | Andre Bergmann |
| 2009-2011 | Marc Rosbach |
| 2011-2016 | Florian Bauer |
| 2016-2021 | Dennis Pacht |
| seit 2021 | Martin Willmeroth |
Ehrenbrudermeister
Zwei Mitglieder der Bruderschaft wurden bislang für Ihre beispielhaftes Engagement zu Ehrenbrudermeistern der Bruderschaft ernannt.
